Shaw
Manchester United
87 1vs1 Index Info icon

0

100

McTominay
Manchester United
80 1vs1 Index Info icon

0

100

vs.

Shaw vs McTominay - who is the better player?

Records
Shaw
McTominay
This team doesn't have any records yet.

Top 10 in Yellow cards
Premier League

Scouting report
Shaw
McTominay
% Per 90 Metric Per 90 %
5.89%
0 Goals 0
8.74%
79.19%
0.97 Key passes 0.65
56.82%
72.94%
87 Pass completion, % 84
55.82%
70.6%
58 Challenges won, % 51
52.98%
27.63%
0 xG conversion 0
30.4%
See full report
Strengths & Weaknesses
Shaw
McTominay
Shaw vs McTominay Detailed Stats
  • Goal icon

    Goals

  • Playmaking icon

    Playmaking

  • Passing icon

    Passing

  • Defense icon

    Defense

Shaw
McTominay
Value
Total
Per 90 min
Metric
Shaw
McTominay
Trends
Performance curve
Market value 2022/2023
Trends
Performance curve
Market value 2022/2023

Compare Yourself

YOU!

vs.

Shaw

Shaw

What's your opinion, who is better? What's your opinion, who is better?
Shaw
Shaw
0%
0 Votes
100%
0 Votes
McTominay
McTominay
Is Shaw better than McTominay? Here is our 1vs1 opinion:

Who has more goals in 2022/2023? Luke Shaw or Scott McTominay?

Arrow down
  • Luke Shaw’s has the following offensive skills. He has 0 goals and a total of 0 shots on goals. This results in a goal conversion rate of 50%. He had a total of 2 big chances. Expected goals can only be provided to logged in users.
  • Scott McTominay has the following offensive skills. He has 0 goals and a total of 0 shots on goals. This results in a goal conversion rate of 40%. He had a total of 4 big chances.

Who has more assists in 2022/2023? Luke Shaw or Scott McTominay?

Arrow down
  • Regarding the passing and playmaking skills we can see the following picture. Luke Shaw has a total of 1 asssists, 9 key passes (these are passes leading to a shot on goal) and he created a total of 7 chances.
  • Scott McTominay has a total of 0 assists, 5 key passes and he created a total of 4 chances.
  • Another important metric to measure the players performance is the pass completion rate in general and more importantly the pass completion rate into the opponents box – because this is where most goals are made. Luke Shaw has a pass completion rate of 47% for passes into the box. Scott McTominay has a pass completion rate of 50% for passes into the box.
  • Expected goals, expected goal build up and expected goal chain value are only visible to our logged in users.

Who is better in defense: Luke Shaw or Scott McTominay?

Arrow down
  • Lets have a look at Luke Shaw’s and Scott McTominay’s defensive skills. Luke Shaw has a total of 3 blocks, 39 aerial duels and a total number of 28 tackles.
  • Scott McTominay has a total of 3 blocks, 35 aerial duels and a total number of 36 tackles.

Summary

Arrow down

Given all statistical values we believe that Luke Shaw is the better player at the moment. Please feel free to discuss with us – the comment box is below. We will be happy to reply.

What do you think? Share your views In the comments
Leave a comment
Name
Email

Leave your e-mail and we'll let you know when somebody has commented

comment
Other comparisons
Luke Shaw
Luke Shaw
vs.
Lionel Messi
Lionel Messi
Compare
Luke Shaw
Luke Shaw
vs.
Mohamed Salah
Mohamed Salah
Compare
Other players
Invite Teammates
you can invite your friend to join 1VS1 and compare with them every time you play a new match